Image 1 of 5
Image 2 of 5
Image 3 of 5
Image 4 of 5
Image 5 of 5
Divorce Is a Deal—Negotiate It Like One
Your Insider Guide to Divorce Settlement Strategy
Chapter 1: Take Back Your Power & Negotiate Your Own Settlement Offer
Divorce isn’t just a legal process—it’s a negotiation. And you’re more capable than you think.
If you’ve been told you’re crazy, overreacting, not smart enough, or not worth listening to—this chapter is for you. Because those are the very messages that keep people stuck, afraid to speak up, and disconnected from their own power. But here’s the truth: you can negotiate a fair settlement. You can advocate for yourself. And you don’t need to know everything to get started—you just need to begin.
Hi, I’m Melissa Gragg. I’m a financial mediator and business valuation expert, and I specialize in divorce settlement strategy. In this guide, I’m going to show you how to create and present your own settlement offer—even when you’re still gathering information or facing a high-conflict spouse. This chapter is about creating your own settlement options, and why making the first offer (yes, even before you hire an attorney or go to court) can dramatically shift the outcome of your case.
Why You Must Lead the Strategy
Too often, women are told to hand everything over to their lawyer and "let the experts handle it." But here’s the problem: no one knows your situation better than you. You’re the one who has lived through the marriage. You know what matters. And while lawyers, financial experts, and parenting specialists are vital to the process, you should be at the center of the strategy—not sidelined by it.
Taking the lead doesn’t mean doing it alone. It means learning how to ask the right questions, gather the right documents, and understand what matters in a settlement—so you can make decisions based on strategy, not fear.
What Does It Mean to Anchor the Deal?
Anchoring is a negotiation tactic where the first number presented becomes the reference point for all other offers. In divorce, this means the first offer you or your spouse puts on the table can “set the tone” for how the rest of the financial discussions unfold.
Let’s say your house is worth $400,000 and your spouse insists it’s worth $200,000. If you make the first offer and anchor it at $400,000—supported with proof like an appraisal or recent comps—now the negotiation starts from your number, not theirs. Even if they don’t agree, the mediator or judge will see your number as more reasonable if you back it with evidence.
The person who speaks first doesn’t lose. They lead.
But What If I Don’t Have All the Documents?
Here’s the good news: most people don’t. Especially early in the process. That’s why your first offer can include assumptions. For example:
"Based on the information currently available, I believe the marital assets total approximately $1.2 million. This includes the house at $400,000, retirement accounts totaling $500,000, and other shared assets worth $300,000. Supporting documents are included where available. Further valuation and documentation is requested for the business and potential separate property claims."
Making an offer—even an initial one—shows initiative and frames you as reasonable, prepared, and willing to settle. And it forces the other party to react. If they disagree, they’ll need to provide their own numbers and evidence.
What Should Be in a Basic Settlement Offer?
A property statement listing all assets and debts
Estimated values with sources (statements, appraisals, etc.)
A proposal for division (what goes to you, what goes to them)
A list of assumptions or missing documents
A narrative summary of major concerns (like separate property claims, business interests, or missing money)
You don’t need to write a 20-page legal brief. You need a clear, reasonable, and well-organized proposal backed by facts.
When You’re Facing a Narcissistic or Toxic Spouse
If you’re dealing with someone who refuses to negotiate in good faith, delays sharing documents, or bullies you into silence, you’re not alone. Many of our clients at The Divorce Allies are navigating high-conflict divorces. That’s why we created this guide.
Anchoring the deal helps you regain a sense of control. It shifts the conversation from emotional chaos to documented reality. You’re not just telling your side of the story—you’re showing it with evidence.
You also don’t have to wait for an attorney to tell you what to do. You can begin now:
Write a one-page summary of your marriage, listing major dates, events, and concerns.
Create a timeline of financial events (big purchases, asset transfers, inheritance, etc.)
Start collecting recent statements for bank accounts, loans, credit cards, investments, and pensions. (12 months of statements, labeled and sorted, even better)
List your top 3 priorities for the outcome of your divorce.
You may not have everything. But you have enough to start.
The Divorce Allies Approach
This free guide features insights from our team of experts in finance, parenting, real estate, small business marketing and trauma-informed negotiation. Our goal is to give you tools to:
Create a practical, powerful settlement offer
Use facts instead of fear
Get organized and stay focused
Know what to ask for and when to ask it
In the next chapters, we’ll cover how to:
Navigate communication and negotiation with a narcissistic spouse
Negotiate a parenting plan that protects your kids
Make smart decisions about the marital home
Control your finances by starting a side-hustle
Be prepared for mediation and pulling it all together for the team
You are not powerless. You are capable. You are not crazy. You are ready.
Let’s start by anchoring the deal.